Disqualification Follows Refusal to Face Trans Competitor

 

A controversy has emerged in the fencing world following the disqualification of Stephanie Turner at the Cherry Blossom Open in Maryland. Turner, 31, was removed from the USA Fencing-sanctioned tournament after she took a knee and refused to compete against transgender athlete Redmond Sullivan.

According to reports, Turner decided to protest USA Fencing's gender eligibility policy, claiming the organization had ignored women's concerns. She stated she made her decision the night before the competition, upon learning she would face Sullivan.

Turner recounted the incident, saying she knelt on the piste and informed the referee she would not compete against Sullivan, citing her belief that it was a women's tournament. Sullivan, who uses she/her pronouns, reportedly believed Turner was injured and approached her. Turner then explained her decision, expressing respect for Sullivan but maintaining her stance.

Sullivan reportedly reminded Turner of the International Fencing Federation (FIE) rule prohibiting refusal to fence a properly entered opponent, warning her of potential disqualification. Turner acknowledged the rule and was subsequently shown a black card, the most severe penalty in fencing, leading to her removal from the tournament.

USA Fencing, in a statement, clarified that Turner's disqualification was solely due to her refusal to fence an eligible opponent, as mandated by FIE rules. They emphasized their commitment to inclusivity while adhering to international standards. The organization also stated that they are committed to a respectful and inclusive community.

The incident has sparked debate about transgender athletes' participation in women's sports. The NCAA changed its policy in February, following an executive order regarding transgender women in sports, but this tournament was not NCAA sanctioned.